Ramanujan: Making sense of 1+2+3+... = -1/12 and Co.
3,866
by Super User, 9 years ago
The Mathologer sets out to make sense of 1+2+3+... = -1/12 and some of those other notorious, crazy-looking infinite sum identities. The starting point for this video is the famous letter that led to the discovery of self-taught mathematical genius Srinivasa Ramanujan in 1913 (Ramanujan is the subject of the movie "The man who knew infinity" that just started showing in cinemas.) Find out about how these identities come up in Ramanujan's work, the role of "just do it" in math, the rules for adding infinite sums on Earth and other worlds, and what all this has to do with the mathematical super star the Riemann Zeta function.
If you want to watch some other videos that deal with these strange identities I recommend the following:
https://youtu.be/0Oazb7IWzbA (a Numberphile video featuring the mathematician Edward Frenkel)
https://youtu.be/XFDM1ip5HdU (a very nice 3Blue1Brown video that makes sense of the identity 1+2+4+8+... = –1 in a way that is totally different from the one I am talking about in this video.)
This week’s video is in response to a large number of you and my students at university asking me for my take on the whole 1+2+3+... =-1/12 business. Initially, the plan was to come up with one of my usual 15 minute long videos. However, after several unsuccessful attempts at not exceeding the magic Mathologer time limit, I realised that any “short” video like this would just be a clone of one of those wrong/misleading accounts of this topic that YouTube is full of. So, rather than just give up completely on this project I decided to do what you should never do if you actually want people to watch your videos, namely simply go for it and not look at the clock. The result – a video that is an insane 35 minutes long in which I say all the things that I think need to be said and can be said only using elementary math to (just barely) do this amazing topic justice.
Enjoy :)
Burkard
P.S.: If you know calculus and want to read up on all this some more, beyond what is readily available via the relevant Wiki pages and other internet resources, I recommend you read the last chapter of the book by Konrad Knopp, Theory and applications of infinite series, Dover books, 1990 (actually if you know German, read the extended version of this chapter in the original 1924 edition of the book). People usually recommend Hardy's (the Hardy I mention at the beginning of the video!) book, Divergent series, but I'd say only look at this after you've looked at Knopp's book which I find a lot more accessible.
If you want to watch some other videos that deal with these strange identities I recommend the following:
https://youtu.be/0Oazb7IWzbA (a Numberphile video featuring the mathematician Edward Frenkel)
https://youtu.be/XFDM1ip5HdU (a very nice 3Blue1Brown video that makes sense of the identity 1+2+4+8+... = –1 in a way that is totally different from the one I am talking about in this video.)
This week’s video is in response to a large number of you and my students at university asking me for my take on the whole 1+2+3+... =-1/12 business. Initially, the plan was to come up with one of my usual 15 minute long videos. However, after several unsuccessful attempts at not exceeding the magic Mathologer time limit, I realised that any “short” video like this would just be a clone of one of those wrong/misleading accounts of this topic that YouTube is full of. So, rather than just give up completely on this project I decided to do what you should never do if you actually want people to watch your videos, namely simply go for it and not look at the clock. The result – a video that is an insane 35 minutes long in which I say all the things that I think need to be said and can be said only using elementary math to (just barely) do this amazing topic justice.
Enjoy :)
Burkard
P.S.: If you know calculus and want to read up on all this some more, beyond what is readily available via the relevant Wiki pages and other internet resources, I recommend you read the last chapter of the book by Konrad Knopp, Theory and applications of infinite series, Dover books, 1990 (actually if you know German, read the extended version of this chapter in the original 1924 edition of the book). People usually recommend Hardy's (the Hardy I mention at the beginning of the video!) book, Divergent series, but I'd say only look at this after you've looked at Knopp's book which I find a lot more accessible.
-
Super User uploaded a new media, Ramanujan: Making sense of 1+2+3+... = -1/12 and Co.
9 years ago
